PHP :: Doc Bug #76875 :: It is not clear what 'uncomparable' means

It is not clear what 'uncomparable' means

Submitted:

2018-09-13 01:11 UTC

Modified:

Votes:	1
Avg. Score:	3.0 ± 0.0
Reproduced:	1 of 1 (100.0%)
Same Version:	0 (0.0%)
Same OS:	0 (0.0%)

From:

manabu dot matsui at gmail dot com

Assigned:

Status:

Open

Package:

Documentation problem

PHP Version:

Irrelevant

OS:

Private report:

CVE-ID:

None

[2018-09-13 01:11 UTC] manabu dot matsui at gmail dot com

Description:
------------
---
From manual page: http://www.php.net/language.operators.comparison
---

In table 'Comparison with Various Types', it is said that 'if key from operand 1 is not found in operand 2 then arrays are uncomparable', and according to Example 2, the standard_array_compare function returns null in that case.

When I actually tried it, each operator returned the following value.

<?php
$x = ['a' => 1];
$y = ['b' => 2];

var_dump($x < $y);   # false
var_dump($x <= $y);  # false
var_dump($x > $y);   # false
var_dump($x >= $y);  # false
var_dump($x <=> $y); # 1
?>

I can not explain this result from the manual description. I think it would be better to explain more clearly.

What is the meaning of 'uncomparable'? For example, the following can be considered

* If $x and $y are uncomparable, $x < $y, $x <= $y, $x > $y, $x >=$y are all false, and $x <=> $y is 1.

* It returns some kind of value, but it is indeterminate what the value is. (The above example happened to be so, in different situations it could be different results)

Patches

Pull Requests

History

[2018-09-13 11:26 UTC] a at b dot c dot de

"Uncomparable" means "cannot be compared". That means there is no well-ordering on arbitrary arrays that allows such comparisons to be made in any sensible fashion (how do _you_ think $x and $y should be ordered?).

['a' => 1] < ['b' => 2], for one, evaluates to FALSE because ['a' => 1] is not less than ['b' => 2]. (The operator is defined as returning TRUE if its left argument is less than its right. This is not the case here.)

In the same way, ['a' => 1] > ['b' => 2] is FALSE because ['a' => 1] is not greater than ['b' => 2] and ['a' => 1] == ['b' => 2] is FALSE because ['a' => 1] is not equal to ['b' => 2].

[2018-09-14 00:34 UTC] manabu dot matsui at gmail dot com

I can see that there are uncomparable arrays. However, it is a problem that what kind of results can be expected (or should not be expected) when doing comparative operations on them is not clear.

For example, if it is guaranteed that $x <= $y and $x> = $y are false for uncomparable arrays $x, $y, then a function to determine whether two arrays can be compared is able to be written as follows:

<?php
function isComparable(array $x, array $y)
{
     return $x <= $y || $x >= $y;
}
?>

If it is not guaranteed (eg like 'undefined behavior' in C or 'unspecified behavior' in Scheme), it must be implemented in a different way.

	php.net \| support \| documentation \| report a bug \| advanced search \| search howto \| statistics \| random bug \| login
go to bug id or search bugs for


Copyright © 2001-2020 The PHP Group All rights reserved.	Last updated: Wed Dec 02 10:01:24 2020 UTC