PHP :: Request #52776 :: MessageFormatter::__construct should throw an exception for invalid patterns

MessageFormatter::__construct should throw an exception for invalid patterns

Submitted:

2010-09-04 23:23 UTC

Modified:

2015-08-07 00:55 UTC

Votes:	6
Avg. Score:	4.7 ± 0.7
Reproduced:	3 of 3 (100.0%)
Same Version:	3 (100.0%)
Same OS:	1 (33.3%)

From:

clicky at erebot dot net

Assigned:

danack (profile)

Status:

Closed

Package:

I18N and L10N related

PHP Version:

Irrelevant

OS:

Ubuntu 9.10

Private report:

CVE-ID:

None

View Developer Edit

[2010-09-04 23:23 UTC] clicky at erebot dot net

Description:
------------
MessageFormatter's constructor returns NULL when an invalid pattern is given.
Instead, it should throw an exception.

This bug has already been reported twice before (see #52042 & #49161). Each time the report was marked as bogus because the real problem got overlooked. (the problem lies not in the given pattern being considered invalid by ICU, the problem is in the constructor returning NULL)

Test script:
---------------
<?php

$f1 = msgfmt_create('en_US', '{this was made intentionally incorrect}');
echo 'f1 is ', gettype($f1), PHP_EOL;

$f2 = MessageFormatter::create('en_US', '{this was made intentionally incorrect}');
echo 'f2 is ', gettype($f2), PHP_EOL;

$f3 = new MessageFormatter('en_US', '{this was made intentionally incorrect}');
echo 'f3 is ', gettype($f3), PHP_EOL;

?>

Expected result:
----------------
f1 is NULL
f2 is NULL
Fatal error: Uncaught exception 'Exception' with message 'Invalid pattern' in %s:%d.

Actual result:
--------------
f1 is NULL
f2 is NULL
f3 is NULL

Patches

Pull Requests

History

AllCommentsChangesGit/SVN commitsRelated reports

[2010-09-05 23:34 UTC] felipe@php.net

-Status: Open +Status: Assigned -Assigned To: +Assigned To: stas

[2011-04-17 23:58 UTC] stas@php.net

-Package: *Languages/Translation +Package: I18N and L10N related

[2011-04-17 23:58 UTC] stas@php.net

-Type: Bug +Type: Feature/Change Request

[2012-02-21 10:20 UTC] jinmoku at hotmail dot com

use the ini directive : intl.error_level

[2012-02-26 12:05 UTC] clicky at erebot dot net

jinmoku at hotmail dot com:

Please read the report again. The documentation on the new operator (http://php.net/manual/en/language.oop5.basic.php#language.oop5.basic.new) states:

"To create an instance of a class, the new keyword must be used. An object will always be created unless the object has a constructor defined that throws an exception on error."

In the context of the "new" keyword, ONLY exceptions may be used to signal errors. In intl's case, "new" returns NULL on errors, which clearly is a bug per the documentation above, regardless of any INI setting the extension may otherwise provide to later change the way it signals errors.

Sorry if I sound rude, but this bug has already been overlooked twice.

Anyway, this bug will probably not be resolved any time soon due to stas' involvement with PHP 5.4. I'm slowly learning about core internals and will try to come up with a patch for this issue when I feel comfortable enough.

[2013-02-17 10:46 UTC] stas@php.net

-Assigned To: stas +Assigned To:

[2015-01-15 20:34 UTC] danack@php.net

-Assigned To: +Assigned To: danack

[2015-01-15 20:34 UTC] danack@php.net

I'm going to look at this - I think it ought to be fixed for 7.

[2015-05-08 08:57 UTC] clicky at erebot dot net

Thanks for looking into this Dan.

I see your RFC on "Constructor behaviour of internal classes" passed and was merged in. I also saw https://git.php.net/?p=php-src.git;a=commitdiff;h=e96616739c2414947197a67fe8af6da594b34762;hp=dd0b602381fad375d8f29a97f25f099be7c9db35 which seems to fix this issue as well as #52776.

I'll try to test this against master soon and report the results here.

[2015-08-07 00:55 UTC] cmb@php.net

-Status: Assigned +Status: Closed

[2015-08-07 00:55 UTC] cmb@php.net

This issue has been resolved with PHP 7, see
<http://3v4l.org/3erK9>.

	php.net \| support \| documentation \| report a bug \| advanced search \| search howto \| statistics \| random bug \| login
go to bug id or search bugs for


Copyright © 2001-2024 The PHP Group All rights reserved.	Last updated: Thu Oct 31 23:01:28 2024 UTC